thumbnail of Van Cliburn International Piano Competition; No. 3; Part 6
Transcript
Hide -
This transcript has been examined and corrected by a human. Most of our transcripts are computer-generated, then edited by volunteers using our FIX IT+ crowdsourcing tool. If this transcript needs further correction, please let us know.
<v Speaker>[Philippe Bianconi and orchestra play piano concerto number 1 Opus 15 by Brahms]. <v Steve Allen>The conductor gives the artist a congratulatory hug, and understandably so.
<v Steve Allen>You've just heard the piano concerto number 1 in D minor, Opus 15 by Brahms. <v Steve Allen>The soloist: Philippe Bianconi of France playing at the Fort <v Steve Allen>Worth Symphony Orchestra conducted by Stanisław Skrowaczewski. <v Paul Hume>Amazing pianist, Steve, at the age of 25, that's one of the big testing concertos. <v Paul Hume>And I thought he stood right up to it and brought it off beautifully. <v Steve Allen>Indeed. <v Steve Allen>The applause as you can hear is still continuing, very vigorous cheering. <v Steve Allen>Now the orchestra rises to pay its respects. <v Steve Allen>Bianconi must be very happy with his performance. <v Steve Allen>And that is the concluding performance on this the third night of the final round in the <v Steve Allen>1985 Van Cliburn International Piano Competition. <v Speaker>[applause continues] <v Steve Allen>The conductor and player leave the stage. <v Steve Allen>So we now have behind us, Paul, all 3 nights in finals competition.
<v Steve Allen>It's all over now but the voting. The jury will deliberate late tonight and again <v Steve Allen>tomorrow morning and they bring Bianconi back for another vigorous <v Steve Allen>round of applause in which the orchestra joins. <v Steve Allen>And then finally at the awards ceremony, we'll find out who it is that <v Steve Allen>will be the gold medalist. <v Steve Allen>The top award, as we mentioned earlier in this competition, is valued at more than 200000 <v Steve Allen>dollars and includes a 12000 dollar cash prize, concert engagements for 2 and <v Steve Allen>a half years, a Carnegie Hall recital, and a debut recording. <v Steve Allen>There's a great deal at stake. And once again, Philippe Bianconi is back <v Steve Allen>on stage with Mr. Skrowaczewski. <v Steve Allen>The orchestra rises and all 3 contributors to a very exciting <v Steve Allen>performance acknowledge the response of the audience. <v Steve Allen>Well, Paul, we're just observing, we've now heard performances by all of the 6 finalists. <v Steve Allen>If you don't mind, may I put you on the spot?
<v Steve Allen>What are your predictions? <v Paul Hume>Well, first of all, let me I urge the audience, as I <v Paul Hume>did 2 nights ago, to be their own judges, to do their own rating. <v Paul Hume>You've heard the 6 semifinalists and the 6 finalists as we have. <v Paul Hume>Remember, of course, the judges are working from their hearing them in their solo <v Paul Hume>performances, in their chamber music, and then in their concertos with the orchestra. <v Paul Hume>I'm willing to go out on a limb, which I think is a fairly strong limb, and <v Paul Hume>give you the names of the top 4 as I see them. <v Paul Hume>First, I'm going to give them to you in purely alphabetical order. <v Paul Hume>I think Philippe Bianconi, Barry Douglas José Feghali, <v Paul Hume>and Hans-Christian Wille are the top 4 players in these <v Paul Hume>final competitions and indeed in the entire Cliburn competition. <v Paul Hume>I've been doing some handicapping as we've been listening and I am now willing <v Paul Hume>to say the order in which I think the judges ought to name <v Paul Hume>them winners tomorrow night.
<v Paul Hume>And I find that they come out exactly the same in my <v Paul Hume>estimation, as they did alphabetically. <v Paul Hume>I would give the gold medal to Philippe Bianconi. <v Paul Hume>I would give the silver medal to Barry Douglas. <v Paul Hume>I would give the third prize to José Feghali and the fourth to Hans-Christian <v Paul Hume>Wille. But there have been 3 ties in past <v Paul Hume>Cliburn competitions. <v Paul Hume>And I can see a real possibility in my own scoring and in my estimation, <v Paul Hume>in a tie for second place between Douglas and Feghali. <v Steve Allen>Hm. <v Paul Hume>That is up to the decision of the judges. <v Paul Hume>But of course, they are, by the way, doing their judging purely by numbers. <v Paul Hume>They turn in a total of numbers. <v Paul Hume>The booklet states quite clearly in the rules that in case of a tie is a tie-breaking <v Paul Hume>mechanism can be invoked. <v Paul Hume>Well, I think it works here exactly as it does in the United States Senate, where the <v Paul Hume>vice president, Mr. Bush, who has a certain standing in Texas, casts the tie-breaking <v Paul Hume>vote. That is the role that John Giordano, who's been our chairman throughout
<v Paul Hume>this and is called a non-voting member of the jury, can step up <v Paul Hume>and vote. We'll see, of course, whether or not there is a tie. <v Paul Hume>As I say, it would not be unprecedented. There have been 3. <v Paul Hume>I would not have a tie. I would give the first prize to Bianconi, the second to Douglas, <v Paul Hume>the third to Feghali, and the fourth to Wille. <v Steve Allen>Very forthright answer. A question, Paul, to employ the analogy with <v Steve Allen>sports again: a prizefighter can lose, let's say, <v Steve Allen>8 rounds in a row and not being battered out of the ring, but losing nevertheless, <v Steve Allen>and then by coming on strong in the last couple of rounds, let's say still save <v Steve Allen>the day or the night. Can anything of that sort happen here? <v Paul Hume>Well, you're talking about a knockout in the ring, of course, which ends the fight and <v Paul Hume>awards the prize to the man who delivered the knockout blow. <v Steve Allen>Well, even if he just doesn't, knock the opponent out, but is much better in the last two <v Steve Allen>rounds. <v Paul Hume>Sure. <v Steve Allen>Yeah. <v Paul Hume>Well, we've had rounds here. Again, I don't know how if the judges <v Paul Hume>are going to devote more weight on the concertos
<v Paul Hume>or more on the chamber music or more, say, on the playing of the Mozart <v Paul Hume>concerto than the later concerto or vise versa and how much consideration they <v Paul Hume>will give in the overall picture to the early rounds solo and also <v Paul Hume>in the semifinals. In addition to the chamber music, each pianist played an hour-long <v Paul Hume>solo recital, all of which, of course, is now in the judges' thinking. <v Paul Hume>We know without question. We don't have to know what the judge is doing. <v Paul Hume>We know that all of these things are now in their minds. <v Paul Hume>They have heard these pianists for 4 hours- 4 and a half hours with the concertos <v Paul Hume>just about a total. And out of all of that. <v Paul Hume>I suspect some of them have as I've- as I have done, already put down their numbers <v Paul Hume>and they're not going to worry about it. One judge said to me yesterday, I knew <v Paul Hume>after the first 15 minutes of each pianist, now that's- that's some going, uh in <v Paul Hume>the first 15 minutes, he hadn't heard the concerto. <v Paul Hume>But maybe he meant the first 15 minutes or the first 10 minutes of their solo recital, <v Paul Hume>the first 10 of their chamber music and the first 10 of their Brahms.
<v Steve Allen>Showed him at least what they were capable of. <v Paul Hume>My feeling is that I heard Bianconi play the most beautiful Mozart <v Paul Hume>that I've heard in these concertos and the only pianist who played a Mozart concerto, <v Paul Hume>which I found satisfying in every respect. <v Paul Hume>Then he came back with the big Brahms, and I heard him again playing the finest big <v Paul Hume>later concerto that I heard. <v Paul Hume>So I had no trouble at all putting him at the top. <v Paul Hume>I found that in my numerical system, Douglas and <v Paul Hume>Feghali are very close together. <v Paul Hume>What the judges would have a matter of points. <v Paul Hume>So we'll see. <v Steve Allen>Yes. And tomorrow is the- when the scene will happen. <v Steve Allen>We'll be bringing you that all-important winners ceremony. <v Steve Allen>In addition, we'll have a chance to recap the competition as a whole. <v Steve Allen>Naturally, no one listening to us was able to hear the entire proceedings. <v Steve Allen>But now, in a sense, you will. <v Steve Allen>We'll bring you a performance of the commissioned piece by John Corigliano, <v Steve Allen>as well as highlights from the chamber music performances with the Tokyo Quartet <v Steve Allen>and at the end of the program will have a chance to speak with Malcolm Frager, one of the
<v Steve Allen>judges here, and he should be able to tell us the details as to <v Steve Allen>how the jury reached its decision. <v Steve Allen>So do be sure to join us again tomorrow night at the same time for our concluding <v Steve Allen>program of this group. The seventh Van Cliburn International Piano Competition is <v Steve Allen>presented by the Van Cliburn Foundation, Fort Worth, Texas, Andrew <v Steve Allen>Raeburn, executive director. If you'd like more information about the Van Cliburn <v Steve Allen>International Piano Competition, the 160-page official souvenir program <v Steve Allen>is available or you have to do to get one to send three dollars to cover postage and <v Steve Allen>handling to Van Cliburn Competition, Box 32 <v Steve Allen>0 7, Fort Worth, Texas 76 1 0 2. <v Steve Allen>Address again. Van Cliburn Competition, Box 3 2 0 7, <v Steve Allen>Fort Worth, Texas 76 1 0 2. <v Steve Allen>Now for KERA Dallas Fort Worth, the technical director has been <v Steve Allen>John Allison. Our broadcast engineer, Mark Lambert.
<v Steve Allen>Remote audio facilities are provided by MidCom Incorporated. <v Steve Allen>Mike Simpson and Jim Fitzgerald engineers. <v Steve Allen>Portable satellite uplink facilities provided by IDB Incorporated. <v Steve Allen>Audio coordinator for the Van Cliburn competition is John Moran. <v Steve Allen>The audio producer is Andrew Raeburn with music feeds <v Steve Allen>provided by digital services. <v Steve Allen>Trent Burns, chief engineer and John Lehman mixer. <v Steve Allen>Steve Proffitt's our features producers- the producer, rather, with reports contributed <v Steve Allen>by Craig Allen, Nancy Lamb, and Chris Douritas US. <v Steve Allen>The assistant director is Jacqueline Cumming and Patricia Silverman is <v Steve Allen>associate producer. And we thank Patricia, Paul and I do for her particular <v Steve Allen>help here in our studio. This program was produced and directed by Ara Guzelimian, <v Steve Allen>the executive producer is Michael Nitka, and this has been a production of <v Steve Allen>KERA Dallas Fort Worth. <v Steve Allen>Paul Hume, once again, it's been a great pleasure for me to have your company for these <v Steve Allen>broadcasts, and I thank you for enlightening me to such a great extent.
<v Steve Allen>Tomorrow, we'll have a chance to compare your predictions, of course, with the jury's <v Steve Allen>decisions. <v Paul Hume>One further word about the required piece by John Corigliano, Steve, not only will <v Paul Hume>we hear that work, which is called "A Fantasia on an Ostinato" and a fascinating piece, <v Paul Hume>but also John Corigliano will tell us which pianist he thinks played it best. <v Paul Hume>And the jury, of course, will give a special prize to the person they think played it <v Paul Hume>best. I can't wait till tomorrow night. <v Paul Hume>Steve, I'll see you then. And then we'll see how smart the jury is. <v Steve Allen>[laughs] All right. That's "Fantasia on an Ostinato," you say? <v Paul Hume>That's right. <v Steve Allen>That'll interest me because I used to drive on ostinato years ago and it finally broke <v Steve Allen>down. <v Paul Hume>They were good cars. <v Steve Allen>[laughs] Nice to end such a dignified program on a silly note, but it's been a rough 3 <v Steve Allen>nights. This is Steve Allen. Thanks for joining us. <v Steve Allen>And please plan to be with us tomorrow night when we resume with coverage of the 1985 <v Steve Allen>Van Cliburn International Piano Competition. <v Steve Allen>Until then, good night from Fort Worth. <v Radio Host>This program was made possible by grants from the Mobil Oil Corporation
<v Radio Host>and Tandy Corporation, RadioShack. <v Radio Host>This is the American Public Radio Network.
Please note: This content is only available at GBH and the Library of Congress, either due to copyright restrictions or because this content has not yet been reviewed for copyright or privacy issues. For information about on location research, click here.
Series
Van Cliburn International Piano Competition
Episode Number
No. 3
Segment
Part 6
Producing Organization
KERA
Contributing Organization
The Walter J. Brown Media Archives & Peabody Awards Collection at the University of Georgia (Athens, Georgia)
AAPB ID
cpb-aacip-2b0cb497b69
If you have more information about this item than what is given here, or if you have concerns about this record, we want to know! Contact us, indicating the AAPB ID (cpb-aacip-2b0cb497b69).
Description
Episode Description
This installment is the third night of the 1785 Van Cliburn Competition. Finalists Hans-Christian Wille and Philippe Bianconi perform. Also featuring interviews with Haywood and Harriet Clemens, who host pianists in their homes in Fort Worth, Texas for the duration of the competition, Eddie Maude Smith, also known as the 'Backstage Mother,' Andrew Raeburn, director of the Van Cliburn competition, Ralph Votapek, winner of the first Van Cliburn competition, and finalists Hans-Christian Wille and Philippe Bianconi.
Series Description
"'The live coverage of the 1985 Van Cliburn International Piano Competition presented some engrossing and engaging live radio. In my book, this is what live broadcast coverage is all about. There was drama, tension, information and sweat-on-the-keyboard excitement.' --Noah Andre Trudeau, Fanfare, Sept.-Oct., 1985 "Pianist/composer/entertainer Steve Allen and music critic Paul Hume co-hosted four nights of live national coverage of the Seventh Van Cliburn International Piano Competition. The coverage was produced by Dallas/Fort Worth public radio station KERA and broadcast nationwide by American Public Radio. "KERA chose to capture the last four nights of the three-week competition -- four dramatic nights when 36 contestants had dwindled to six finalists who would perform with the Forth Worth Symphony Orchestra under the baton of Stanislaw Skrowaczewski. Here were supremely talented young musicians battling to win one of the world's most prestigious music competitions. The winner would receive prized valued at more than a quarter million dollars and, more importantly, an ideal springboard for a concert career. "Allen and Hume contributed style and visibility to the coverage. Allen is known for many performance achievements outside of classical music. Hume is recognized as a leading American classical critic. Their chemistry provided insight, depth and humor. Listeners unversed in classical music were attracted to listen by Allen's presence and could identify with his 'every-man' approach and questions to Hume; Hume provided the commentary and criticism required by the serious music listeners. "These were concert programs, but more to the point, these were programs with compelling stories to tell: the stories of young artists striving to excel; of musicians from around the globe with their adopted host families in Fort Worth, Texas; of the monumental task of keeping a dozen fine concert grands tuned during three weeks of Texas heat; and, inevitable, of competitors' losing what they wanted most to win. "There were other stories: the guest conductor with five days to prepare an orchestra to perform 12 concertos with six different soloists; the Competition's birth during the Cold War; the task of jurors who were charged with quantifying the unquantifiable; the Forth Worth matron who has served as surrogate mother to competitors for 23 years; the previous winners and the Competition's effect on their careers. "The programs ask, tell, laugh, share, probe, inform -- and revel in the artistry and beauty of it all."1985 Peabody Awards entry forms
Broadcast Date
1985-06-01
Asset type
Episode
Media type
Sound
Duration
00:35:49.968
Credits
Producing Organization: KERA
AAPB Contributor Holdings
The Walter J. Brown Media Archives & Peabody Awards Collection at the University of Georgia
Identifier: cpb-aacip-09c206833b2 (Filename)
Format: 1/4 inch audio cassette
If you have a copy of this asset and would like us to add it to our catalog, please contact us.
Citations
Chicago: “Van Cliburn International Piano Competition; No. 3; Part 6,” 1985-06-01, The Walter J. Brown Media Archives & Peabody Awards Collection at the University of Georgia, American Archive of Public Broadcasting (GBH and the Library of Congress), Boston, MA and Washington, DC, accessed August 2, 2025, http://americanarchive.org/catalog/cpb-aacip-2b0cb497b69.
MLA: “Van Cliburn International Piano Competition; No. 3; Part 6.” 1985-06-01. The Walter J. Brown Media Archives & Peabody Awards Collection at the University of Georgia, American Archive of Public Broadcasting (GBH and the Library of Congress), Boston, MA and Washington, DC. Web. August 2, 2025. <http://americanarchive.org/catalog/cpb-aacip-2b0cb497b69>.
APA: Van Cliburn International Piano Competition; No. 3; Part 6. Boston, MA: The Walter J. Brown Media Archives & Peabody Awards Collection at the University of Georgia, American Archive of Public Broadcasting (GBH and the Library of Congress), Boston, MA and Washington, DC. Retrieved from http://americanarchive.org/catalog/cpb-aacip-2b0cb497b69