thumbnail of Changing World; 8; South African Essay, Part 2: One Nation, Two Nationalisms. Reel 1
Transcript
Hide -
This transcript was received from a third party and/or generated by a computer. Its accuracy has not been verified. If this transcript has significant errors that should be corrected, let us know, so we can add it to FIX IT+.
You don't. The Boeing program is from any need to be the National Educational Television Network. Africans want to share in the whole of South Africa above all. We want political rights because without them the abilities will be coming. I know this song that evolution of the two the whites in this country because the majority of voters will be Africans. I guess you know likely would. Although I do and it being prepared
voluntarily to do and other people to obtain the government and to deny them that right often that it will solve it in the next. You know the list as far as I can see the whites will oppose any measure that may eventually lead to their political subservience. At a time when white rule has ended on most of the African continent and Africa nationalism has emerged as the dominant force in a bloc of independent African states. The Republic of South Africa has become an isolated bastion of white nationalism. Within South Africa today the whites have a firm hold on the government. The country's enormous wealth and its armed might but the opposing force is a black nationalist while temporarily suppressed or favored for ultimate success by their overwhelming strength of numbers with in South Africa reinforced by the sympathy of the
Afro-Asian world. Was was was. It is changing rules to raise the National Educational Television network presents the second of two hour long essays on South Africa one nation two nationally. Here and it will be a small town near Johannesburg. Members of the Nationalist Party have gathered to celebrate its 50th anniversary and to listen to an address from their party leader and Prime Minister Dr. Henry Cavill.
Arriving with his wife. Oh no. In addition to his position as the principal political leader of his country Dr Fay voted the spokesman of the Afrikaner descendants of the early Dutch settlers who have preserved their special culture and their language. South Africa's 17 million population almost 20 percent are white. This is by far the biggest white minority in Africa in the past there have been bitter rivalries particularly between the Afrikaners and the English speaking group that is traditional cleavages now and nearly feel the desperate challenge of African nationalism within the country and pressures from the rest of the continent and
the world community have produced a new white solidarity. I supported by an exclusively white electorate the Nationalist Party has been in power continuously since 1948. Since then its basic policy has been to advocate the complete separation of the races that is the policy apart eight apart it is an Afrikaner word which literally mean a mess. The party is in opposition to the government have been steadily losing ground. The morale of the Nationalist Party base stronger than ever. Feeling.
Good nation we know. Anderson from the. Because we know the piece.
Dr. Fairfax principal of white rule faces the resolute opposition of the indigenous black African majority African nationalism has been organized and active on a countrywide basis for over 15 years until recently. Get it here do a course of nonviolent resistance. But its forces have been ruthlessly suppressed by the government. The two major African parties the African National Congress and the Pan-Africanist Congress have been banned. The principle leaders of these parties driven underground into exile or jail. The conflict of nationalism is brought into focus by the eminent authority on South Africa
Dr. Gwendolyn Carter director of the African Studies program at Northwestern University former president of the African Studies Association and advisor to the United States State Department. Well what we have in South Africa is two nationalisms confronting each out there Afrikaner nationalism the dominant group among so wide. And African nationalism by far the dominant group among They know on the wide and the largest numerical group within the context of Afrikaner nationalism is politically in control. It has many powers many sources of our. It has built up to 300 years. Existence in the southern part of the continent it has all that time being concerned to preserve its own indented to its being fearful of the majority group which it confronted. It has
built itself a position of power in the economy and certainly in politics. I would be fearful of losing this. The big stream very difficult for it to yield even with adequate guarantees ever have it. The individual positions of its members but certainly with out one finds it very difficult to and believe that it would yield its privileged position. But on the other hand is the majority position of the African. They do not have political power. They do not have any administrative opportunities. They have no ever had a nationalist movement of their own. It has operated on the edge of illegality ever since it was formed in 1912. Not a fan of our government has today successfully suppressed black nationalism. It has gone on to ensure the favored position of the white minority with increasingly severe measures under the policy of apartheid strict segregation and white
domination are enshrined in law. Recently the government has preferred to refer to its racial policy as a separate development. Its about purpose is to group of people according to their racial and tribal origins so that each can develop to the maximum potential. Separate development would ultimately reverse the magnetic attraction of the cities to which an ever increasing number of black Africans migrate. As a temporary solution in urban centers like Johannesburg the government counters the force of economic integration by locating Africans in black ghettos on the fringes of the cities. From here Africans commute to jobs in the mines industrial plants and other employment created by the white man's prosperity. By classifying all urban Africans as temporary migrants. The government
claims it is justified in depriving them of social and political rights in the urban areas. The final solution. Under separate development the relocation of all these black Africans in self-governing homelands. If successful separate development would achieve the greatest involuntary transfer of peoples in modern times. The government tries to justify its plans for the Bantu people to the outside world. Bantu is the official term for black Africans. The minister of information Frank Waring relates racial problems in his country to those in the United States. May I submit to you an interesting point. You take the position in the United States should there have been 600 million needed as against the hundred and eighty million people. I would say then you may have had a different approach to your problem than you have
today. Well now that is a proportion really where South Africa has the black people as against the right people. We looked at you in the United States in thinking terms of one nation but in South Africa we have at least eight different nations and eventually nations have got their own culture and concept of civilization traditions and even different languages so that it's quite impossible to think in terms of one single nationalism that we endeavor to separate the various nations and give them the opportunities in that place. Or. The creation of Black African national homelands called Bantustans is the key to Prime Minister favors plan for the survival of South Africa under control. What the government intends is to
take the so-called native reserves and consolidate them into eight Bantustans with a measure of self rule. If all the Africans were relocated on these almost 70 percent of the country's total population would be living on 13 percent of the land. It should be noted that the bantustans are gerrymandered to exclude all of South Africa's known mineral deposits. Big cities and develop sea ports. So far only one Bantustan has been established. The trans guy the trans guy is about one third the size of the state of Louisiana and has a population of about
two million people. The cause a tribe is essential to take a hard and detailed look at the trans guy because the government uses it as its most important showcase for its policy of separate development. This is a trans guy even a kind of tribal town meeting. Following tribal tradition this man is employed to greet the assembling crowd and whip up enthusiasm for the. Speaker Jay Mills wield a great deal of power in the administration of the trans guy government as its principal white civil servant.
Eat. Eat. Eat eat. You have a.
Line
that we should try. It is a young South African journalist who has visited the trans guy frequently and studied its problems as a voluntary exile in the United States. He is now free to voice criticism. The people of the Thais guy did not ask for self-rule fact he has been given to them by the government. They say Lou is an indication that this is is in fact any imposition to be a rare that people should resist their own determination. If it is offered to them the chief minister of the trans guy Chief Kaiser my tuns a man who was interviewed in his office in the capital city one feels that it is not all probably all outside the
world to see that the Republican government has in polls these can be seen on their terms and people think about the making of the trans guy and tell him to a lot of quality. And. It has been. Proved just as it was. In the confusion. We have been given six departments we asked for them. The Republican government is ready to give us more departments. That the bells and tire on the planet and people. Feel that we. Must at present prove ourselves in these these departments. To inform you that the ministers who are been elected. To take charge of the department have done very good work.
The jurisdiction which the SO and government of the tenth guy has over the trans guy is limited to the rural areas it is a rural jurisdiction they're very capital contactor they speak of the supposed chance GUYON government headed by Chief Minister K. the Montana is a right turn for practical purposes you can go into the hotels in the town itself while they're there is there for white people. 10 and I'm still pay those African governments. I think he's intelligent I think he's a vicious. He believes he's playing a shrewd game I think he hates white people enough. Never to want to sell out to them. The people of the trans guy expressed their true feelings in their first election by roundly defeating the party which supports hate and done a lot. But only
45 of the 109 members of the assembly are elected by the people. They majority are chiefs appointed and paid by the South African government. Indeed it was this rigged majority which selected guided Matanzima as their chief minister. In the Transkei Legislative Assembly white civil servants assist African ministers. You know all this that the government of South Africa and this is the only government there really is in South Africa to retain the power they were authority to reject or nullify any legislation which this supposed government of trance guy produces none of the legislation that the transparent government produces from its House
of Assembly can become law without the approval of the government. The plants died today in a peaceful country and I do inform you a lot of times people have accepted the policy of separate development. Knowledge was elected to the Legislative Assembly as a member of the party in opposition to Matanzima. Zeina disagrees with the fundamentals of the trans guy plan. To my mind it can not be economical as a state. We feel that it is inextricably bound up with the economy of the rest of the Republic and its development depends wholly on its close association with the rest of it it probably is hot off the Republic of South Africa. They use very little wealth in their plans. Guy the Transco ions will. Probably develop
agriculture only produce small food than they are producing at the present moment and the irrigation scheme which has been started in their prime out there may well assist them in that direction but it will not be sufficient to support the people of the trans sky sufficiently to make the country economically viable. Considering the unique importance the government attaches to the trans guy it is doing very little to assist in its development. They come out of the irrigation scheme with its impressive little damage has been internationally advertised. This scheme will assist in agricultural development but it will not supply power for industry. Industry is limited to a furniture factory and a few other small plants. Cheap labor is still the main export.
Many workers commute to New factories cropping up in the white areas immediately outside the trans guy border. These factories are given many special advantages by the South African government. Among white South Africans there are many shades of opposition to the government's separate development policy. Author Alan Payton is head of the Liberal Party. More than half of whose members are black Africans and only needed in the future for the African people want to lead a separate development and maybe future for a few Chief Ministers and cabinet ministers and can appreciate those people I meant. That a country like the plant. I can see no point in going to the become a viable proposition that lifetime pecans inseparably bound up with riches at the time and the happiness of the people in the intemperately bound up would be like taking out the poor agricultural section of the United
States and giving it complete autonomy. The bitterness of African. Policy as an excuse to do what with African and African countries.
There are some people who believe the government's plan for separate development doesn't go far enough. They advocate partitioning the country into two separate states. Scott being our assistant editor of the newspaper de Bourgogne reminds us that partitioning has frequently taken place elsewhere in the world. But some of the problems in modern times are that. The atoms of the Jews in Palestine. And of the 100 and in the year. That was stolen by I think the country. So there you have it and the Arab countries and in you you have been you and buddies done. Something similar would have to be a genius I think. And. We started out of that by the creation of the time sky which is
not yet a sovereign country but he's on his way to freedom. And that I haven't asked to be followed throughout South Africa until we have achieved separate freedom between black and white. Neither one is subservient to the other. Handful of white South Africans is actually preparing to accept the sacrifices which back Titian would demand of them. What do you know how white people skilled labor and. But that be done by a teacher.
And as with most things we believe that Dr. Gwendolyn Carter sees strong reason why partition should not take place in South Africa. I think the that policy in regard to trans guy and edited data leads to thoughts of partition. The whole policy of separate development suggests that and I believe it is very important to recognize that now that the Africans on one side or the northern white really want this are taken very seriously at this point. The Africans don't want to brag Mantid can't pray. They believe they belong to all of South Africa and would like to share in it. And certainly the whites have this extremely integrated economic structure. So I feel that only some desperate emergency internal or
external would create that climate of opinion in which it would be at all possible and if it did take place it would have to be a division not only of land area but also there which was Doris's industrial potential of the count. That is a very sobering thought. Having considered the various possibilities for separate development ranging from the trans guy as a model to stand of the radical surgery of partition it is apparent that the government is not investing nearly enough money or effort to achieve success. In all honesty one is forced to question the sincerity of its motives. Does the government want to viable independent trans guy or is it merely a useful propaganda device. Beyond the question of separate development for the black African majority the Nationalist government has further complicated the country's racial problems by creating two other classifications
of so-called non whites colored and Asian. There are over one and a half million colored people of mixed ancestry. And a half million Asians who are mostly Indian. The majority of the Indians live in that our province especially in its principal port Durban. The first were brought in as laborers later Indian shopkeepers and business men came on their own. Indians have been highly successful in running businesses but racial restrictions severely limit the expansion of their enterprises. In Russia. As with other non-whites the government has been operating Indians from their homes and places of business. About 90 percent of the Indian population live in the city in Devon. The
government plans to relocate the entire Indian community about a third of the city's total population. In new segregated Township. The majority of the colored live in the Southern Cape province of any other dominant group include people of mixed European African and Malay descent. In some cases stemming from the earliest white settlements in the 1850s under British rule Khaled Said the right to vote in the Cape Province. But gradually since the 1930s most of these rights have been whittled away. Now I'm officially it is still possible for a few colored and whites to meet socially especially after dark. Over the years many educated and wealthy colored Asians were inclined to identify with the whites and their advanced standard of living
but by depriving the Colored of most political and social rights the government has been giving them common cause with the African one finds a growing sense of unity among all a nonwhite South Africa. If. It is in the urban areas centered around mining and industrial enterprise that the whole elaborate structure of apartheid and separate development breaks down about one fourth of the country's total population now live in the urban cluster which constitutes a kind of Johannesburg megalopolis. A.
Series
Changing World
Episode Number
8
Episode
South African Essay, Part 2: One Nation, Two Nationalisms. Reel 1
Producing Organization
WGBH Educational Foundation
National Educational Television and Radio Center
National Educational Television and Radio Center
Contributing Organization
WGBH (Boston, Massachusetts)
AAPB ID
cpb-aacip/15-8279d3wg
NOLA Code
CGGW
If you have more information about this item than what is given here, or if you have concerns about this record, we want to know! Contact us, indicating the AAPB ID (cpb-aacip/15-8279d3wg).
Description
Episode Description
The second part of 'South African Essay' examines the political machinery which enforces Apartheid-- the South African government's policy of separate government."--1965 Peabody Digest. Includes interviews with blacks and whites who support separatism, and with blacks and whites who oppose it. Discusses the status of Asians and 'coloreds', South Africa's other racial groups, and compares the status of blacks in South African and the United States. Includes footage of Nationalist Party rally, with speech by Prime Minister Hendrik Verwoerd; a Transkei town meeting, with a speech by Chief Mantanzima; Transkei farm and village life; a meeting of the Transkei Parliament; city life in Umtata, Durban and Cape Town; Indians at a children's race; and a gold refinery. Includes footage of the Sharpeville Massacre and its aftermath, including Nelson Mandela's trial. Also includes footage of Achkar Marof of Guinea and Adlai Stevenson of the U.S. addressing the United Nations. At a time when white rule has ended on most of the African continent and African nationalism has emerged as the dominant force, the Republic of South Africa has become an isolated bastion of white nationalism. Within South Africa today the whites have a firm hold on the government, the country's enormous wealth and its armed might. "One Nation, Two Nationalisms," the second part of Changing World: South African Essay, examines the political machinery that enforces Apartheid - the South African government's policy of separate development - and considers the views of noted African spokesmen, whites and blacks alike, who support of oppose the policy. Through documentary film footage and a series of exclusive interviews, the program focuses on the power of the country's totally white Nationalist party, Prime Minister Hendrik Verwoerd's "Bantustan" policy of strict separation of people according to racial and tribal origins, the further complication of the racial problem resulting from the government's creation of two other classifications of non-whites - the Coloreds and the Asians, prospects for total partition of blacks and whites, the government's repression of African political parties, and reaction in the world community to the South African government's Apartheid policy. Dr. Gwedolyn Carter, director of the African Studies Program of Northwestern University and an advisor to the U.S. State Department, describes the conflict between the two nationalisms - the Afrikaner nationalism, the dominant group among whites, and African nationalism, by far the largest numerical group in the country. Frank Waring, South African Minister of Information, relates his country's racial problem to those of the United States. Nat Nakasa, a South African journalist forced into exile, contends that self-rule in the Transkei - the only "Bantustan" set up to date - was imposed by the South African government and not requested by the people. He points out that the party supporting Apartheid was defeated in the first Transkei election, and yet, the South African government retains the power and authority to reject or nullify any legislation which the Transkei government produces. Knowledge Guzana, an elected member of the legislative assembly from the Transkei opposition party which favors a multi-racial state, disagrees with the fundamentals of the Transkei plan. He contends that the economy of the state is tied together with the economy of the republic and its development depends solely on a close association between the two. Among the many whites who agree with Mr. Guzana is author Alan Paton, head of the Liberal Party. He explains why he and his party identify with the majority black African view. A devoted Afrikaner, Scott Pinaar, editor of the newspaper, Die Burger, carries the "Bantustan" policy further. Comparing the South African racial issue to the problems of the Arabs and the Jews in Palestine and the Hindus and Mohammedans in India, he calls for the complete partition of the blacks and whites. Jean Sinclair, president of the Black Sash, a women's protest group, condemns the Pass Laws, a key weapon for white control, which requires that Africans carry a reference document or book known as "passes" in order to get work. This law was responsible for the Sharpeville massacre of 1960 in which seventy two Africans were killed and eighty six wounded during a protest demonstration against "passes." Speaking on behalf of the moderates - a once strong voice among whites, now for the most part grown silent - Colin Eglin points out that many white South Africans, though unhappy with Apartheid, see no alternative. He says that should political control ever slip into the hands of the black man, a period of oppression against the white man would follow and wipe him out economically and politically. Noble Peace Prize winner Chief Albert Luthuli, patriarch of the freedom movement and president of the outlawed African National Congress, has long been an exponent of non-violent protest. He explained why he has now aligned himself with the black African consensus in accepting the use of violence. Raymond Kunene, a leading member of the African National Congress in exile, and Z.B. Molete, London representative of another outlawed party, the Pan African Congress, both states it is inevitable that the black African use violent means to throw off his white oppressor. South African Essay is a 1965 National Educational Television production produced for NET by WGBH, Boston's educational station. This program was originally shot on film. (Description adapted from documents in the NET Microfiche)
Series Description
To give American television viewers a clearer understanding of how the rapid and radical changes now underway in other lands will influence their own lives, National Educational Television launched an incisive bi-monthly series of one-hour documentaries filmed around the globe. Entitled "Changing World," the series premiered in October 1964 on NET's nationwide network of 82 affiliated non-commercial stations. "We believe the scope and design of this series should place it among the season's most important ventures in public affairs television," said William Kobin, director of public affairs programs at NET. "Changing World" will look at the peaceful and not so peaceful revolutions of the mid-twentieth century from the vantage point of the people most deeply and painfully involved in transition. In a systematic way, it will attempt to relate the problems of the various nations and continents to one another, and to the lives of all of us in the United States. "In 'Changing World,'"says Mr. Kobin, "NET has deliberately turned away form a shotgun approach where we would examine only headline-making events. Instead, our producers and their units will be developing, in each instance an organized approach which will afford not only a solid introduction to other peoples and their problems, but a reliable basis on which viewers can judge United States policy, involvement and goals on other continents." (Description adapted from documents in the NET Microfiche)
Broadcast Date
1965-06-30
Asset type
Episode
Genres
Documentary
Topics
Social Issues
Global Affairs
Race and Ethnicity
Public Affairs
Politics and Government
Media type
Moving Image
Duration
00:33:01
Embed Code
Copy and paste this HTML to include AAPB content on your blog or webpage.
Credits
: Eglin, Colin
Associate Producer: Chutter, Cynthia
Associate Producer: Bywaters, Thomas
Associate Producer: Jeffries, Peter
Associate Producer: Bywaters, Thomas
Camera Operator: Filgate, Terence
Director: Macartney-Filgate, Terence
Director: Macartney-Filgate, Terence
Editor: Bywaters, Tom
Interviewee: Paton, Alan
Interviewee: Luthuli, Albert
Interviewee: Waring, Frank
Interviewee: Nakasa, Nat
Interviewee: Kuene, Raymond
Interviewee: Sinclair, Jean
Interviewee: Carter, Gwendolyn
Interviewee: Pinaar, Scott
Interviewee: Guzana, Knowledge
Interviewee: Molete, Z. B.
Producer: Morgenthau, Henry, 1917-
Producer: Morgenthau, Henry, 1917-
Producing Organization: WGBH Educational Foundation
Producing Organization: National Educational Television and Radio Center
Producing Organization: National Educational Television and Radio Center
Speaker: Stevenson, Adlai
Speaker: Mathanzima, Kaiser
Speaker: Marof, Achkar
Speaker: Verwoerd, Hendrik
Writer: Morgenthau, Henry, 1917-
Writer: Morgenthau, Henry, 1917-
Writer: Eglin, Colin
AAPB Contributor Holdings
WGBH
Identifier: 59791 (WGBH Barcode)
Format: Digital Betacam
Generation: Master
Duration: 00:32:29
Indiana University Libraries Moving Image Archive
Identifier: [request film based on title] (Indiana University)
Format: 16mm film
If you have a copy of this asset and would like us to add it to our catalog, please contact us.
Citations
Chicago: “Changing World; 8; South African Essay, Part 2: One Nation, Two Nationalisms. Reel 1,” 1965-06-30, WGBH, American Archive of Public Broadcasting (GBH and the Library of Congress), Boston, MA and Washington, DC, accessed October 18, 2024, http://americanarchive.org/catalog/cpb-aacip-15-8279d3wg.
MLA: “Changing World; 8; South African Essay, Part 2: One Nation, Two Nationalisms. Reel 1.” 1965-06-30. WGBH, American Archive of Public Broadcasting (GBH and the Library of Congress), Boston, MA and Washington, DC. Web. October 18, 2024. <http://americanarchive.org/catalog/cpb-aacip-15-8279d3wg>.
APA: Changing World; 8; South African Essay, Part 2: One Nation, Two Nationalisms. Reel 1. Boston, MA: WGBH, American Archive of Public Broadcasting (GBH and the Library of Congress), Boston, MA and Washington, DC. Retrieved from http://americanarchive.org/catalog/cpb-aacip-15-8279d3wg